Journalism: Populist or Responsible

National Press Day 2026 produced a rare consensus across Nagaland. From Dimapur to Kohima, speakers agreed that journalism must be accurate, independent and accountable. The consensus is welcome. It is also, in places, too comfortable.

The theme, “Journalism: Populist or Responsible,” was treated largely as a binary, and the reports show how differently its two halves were understood. One theme speaker held that responsibility must be defined by who journalists are responsible towards, and described the pressures exerted by communities and leaders to avoid reporting on certain individuals because of their affiliations. Another warned that populism in the Nagaland context can be driven by divisive interests, and that journalists must neither endorse outrage blindly nor align with powerful institutions. Taken together, these remarks point to a difficulty the day’s speeches only touched upon - in a small society with dense community ties, the pressure to self-censor is rarely announced. It arrives quietly, through kinship, community loyalty and political patronage.

That the state government was among the organisers of a commemoration devoted to press independence merits some reflection. The Advisor for Information and Public Relations urged journalists to place facts above popularity, and listed welfare measures - a Journalist Welfare Fund, operational subsidies, accreditation, tablets for working journalists and health insurance cover. These are legitimate and useful. Yet one editor observed, with commendable candour, that dependence on government advertising can create pressure on editorial independence. Welfare and advertising are not the same as influence, but a press reliant on state support must be able to demonstrate that scrutiny of the same state has not softened. The Dimapur Press Club’s appeal for the government to treat the press as a “partner” deserves similar caution. Watchdogs are rarely partners to those they watch.

Economic fragility, acknowledged repeatedly, is the structural weakness beneath the ethical debate. Rising printing costs, declining circulation, shrinking advertising and newspaper closures were all cited. Exhortations to prioritise credibility over clicks ring hollow when the business model rewards neither. Calls for diversified revenue were made, but no concrete proposals, such as reader-supported models, collaborative newsrooms or transparent disclosure of government advertising, were reported. Principles without funding remain aspirations.

Technology received a more balanced treatment. The warning that artificial intelligence can generate fabricated images and cloned voices was sound, as was the reminder that legal and moral responsibility rests with humans. The argument that AI cannot visit a remote village or verify official records captures what distinguishes reporting from content production. The call to engage with independent creators, rather than dismiss them as non-journalists, was perhaps the most forward-looking position voiced. It sits uneasily, however, with another speaker’s view that the defining difference lies in verification. The two positions can be reconciled only if verification, not employment by a newsroom, is accepted as the standard for credibility, and if the profession is prepared to apply that standard to its own members as rigorously as to outsiders.

Perhaps the most valuable observations concerned content. Local and vernacular newspapers, it was noted, report damaged village roads, teacher shortages and understocked health centres that national media overlook. This is the strongest argument for the regional press, and it implies a measurable test: coverage of governance failures in remote areas, not attendance at ceremonies. The call for investigative and interpretive reporting, beyond the stenographic recording of statements and counter-statements, points in the same direction.

Absent from most of the reported speeches was any account of the press’s own shortcomings in the region, whether instances of unverified reporting, communal framing or deference to powerful figures. Ritual affirmations of responsibility are easily made on a commemorative day. Their worth is established in newsrooms on ordinary days.

The remark that journalists are “ants” who are nonetheless powerful carries a truth. Collective persistence, and not individual heroism, sustains accountability. For the media fraternity in Nagaland, the task now is to convert shared sentiment into shared practice including independent funding, transparent ethics, rigorous verification and the courage to report on the powerful, including those within one’s own community.
 



Support The Morung Express.
Your Contributions Matter
Click Here