Dr John Mohan Razu
Professor of Social Ethics
Years ago, “The Times of India” in its daily dated July 2nd 2018, page 8, carried out a short clip titled “Why tolerance isn’t the answer to intolerance” which after 8-years echoing relevance and contextuality in a world ridden by conflicts and wars. The clip starts with a couple of questions: “Could you be friends with someone you merely tolerate? Would you look forward to meeting this person? F you were made a team, how long would it last? Why then, has tolerance—especially religious tolerance—become so important a principle of governance? Why is it seem as “inherent good”, a necessary individual ethic, a pillar of Western civilisation and proof of its superiority?” All these questions even now is relevant and more apt than before.
Continuing further, “While tolerance is certainly a pragmatic policy when tensions between people are running high, does it deserve to be regarded as a virtue? German writer Goethe said: “To tolerate is to insult.” Simon Rabinovitch, who touches history at Boston University, is one of the moder ‘tolerance sceptics. “It is time to dispense once and for all with tolerance as a model for relations between groups”, he writes in Aeon. The writer digs into that whether “Is he advocating intolerance, violence, bloodshed? Far from it, Rabinovich is against religious tolerance because, instead of engaging different religions on equal terms, it only seeks to “main the power and purity of the dominant religion in a given state.”
Developing his arguments further, “That sees the exact opposite of what we think tolerance is, but Rabinovitch says it has been a “means for the majority to regulate the minority,” from the beginning.” Substantiating further, “When Christianity spread, the early Christian church had to fight out how to “live peacefully with people they believed to have crucified their god”. Many centuries later, Protestants and Catholics were at war for more than a hundred years before accepting that some tolerance would be necessary “in places where the balance of military power was not held overwhelmingly by one group or another.”
Expanding on it, the author continues “Tolerance was a compromise, not a positive idea. Even in Aerica, “protection of individual religious conscience becomes necessary as a means for the various colonial powers to administer their territories. Karl Popper said, “the repression of some intolerant views was essential for self-preservation.” Then the asks a question: “What’s wrong with a compromise that ensures peace? Rabinovich says it is “a one-way relationship between the tolerating and the tolerated.” “The tolerated people – who are in a minority – are part of society. Tolerance shuts the door on ‘reciprocity’ or a two-way exchange of culture and ideas which is essential for making strong and dynamic societies.”
And so, “History has left us no examples of civilisations that have flourished without the exchange of cultures, ideas and people.” Rabinovich says “what the world needs is reciprocity, rather than religious tolerance.” Reciprocity is a philosophy a social ethic, a way of seeing the world, and a psychology. At its most basic distillation, it can serve as a description of both what binds’ individuals and groups to and within a society and the mutual exchange of culture that serves as the lifeblood of all prosperous societies.”
In tune to this, “Greater cultural exchange and acknowledgement of the minority’s contributions will ensure that society and its constituent groups feel bound to each other strongly and equally.”Nowadays we keep hearing ‘zero tolerance’ that the perpetrators keep sloganizing. In an unequal and asymmetric divisive societies where those in majority continue to wield their power and authority on those communities and populations who tend to become targets.
Majoritarianism is growing almost in all societies in the name of xenophobia, Islamophobia, casteism, racism, religious fundamentalism, gender divides, and many others triggered by socio-economic, religio-cultural facets. In unequal societies, we have been witnessing fragmentation filled with all sorts of hatred and spite, and in such settings the concept called as ‘tolerance’ is used by the perpetrators who are intolerant towards others. A question that keeps lingering is: who has to tolerate with who? It should be answered by those who have been receiving all sorts of bashing and tortures by the majoritarian.
Ideas have to be grounded on life-enhancing, not life-negating. History shows us that wherever there was destruction of life based on the ideologies such as fascism, Zionism, racism, casteism, religious fundamentalism and majoritarianism genocides we come across destruction of human lives. Those clouded with ideas fail to generate life, rather involve in destructive ideas of life. Ideas that generate life will be life-promoting. Take for instance, Lenin, Stalin, Mussolini, Mao, Hitler and religious conflicts shows how politics, economics, socio-cultural ideas if turned in the wrong-side become destructive. All the destruction was premised on hideous ideas.
The world is gripped with ideas that seem to be attractive for some, but many suffer if they are employed for the benefit of a few. The people at large across the world are suffering with such destructive ideas. For example, the Middle-East is the classic example where an ideology—Jewish Zionism and Russian war against Ukraine are premised on occupation and annexation. The conflicts across the world show such uncanny animosities within and between people. Manipur is again an example where people suffer because of divisive ideology.
Any idea, dogma, creed, or doctrine ought to promote life in all its fullness. At the same time, Homo sapiens are inherently conflicted—capable of great goodness, yet in recent times, we increasingly encounter people driven by diabolical and anti-human ideas. Genocidal, destructive, racial, and divisive mindsets appear to be on the rise. Demonic ideas and fake-narratives ought to be countered by all means by evolving counters—be it social, political, ideological, cultural, or religious. We don’t live at the ‘end of history’ or ‘end of ideology’. History continues to recur and ideologies continues to shape political vision. Discernment is essential in a world of cut-throat competition and destruction of human civilisation.