Whose tourism is it?

A rare convergence was achieved at the recent seminar on ecotourism at Nagaland University. Academics, activists, practitioners and officials agreed that tourism in Nagaland must be community-centred. But agreement on a principle is not the same as readiness to act on it, and the gaps between the two deserve scrutiny.

The strongest argument was that tourism does not arrive in an empty landscape. Land in Nagaland is owned by communities, not the state, and this is protected by Article 371A. Hills are lived in, farmed and governed, so projects planned as though they were blank slates are bound to fail. The questions proposed for every project, who decides, who invests, who benefits, and who bears the loss if it fails, are simple but rarely asked before sanctions are issued. Too often, the department files a report on physical and financial targets while maintenance of half-used assets is left to the village.

Yet some claims need qualification. Article 371A was rightly cited as unique, but its limits were also noted: it creates space and is not self-executing. This is the central problem. Protection exists on paper, while the machinery for exercising it is weak. Village councils are often asked to evaluate investors, contracts and environmental thresholds without legal, financial or technical support. Consent is meaningless if information is withheld, and signatures collected in haste cannot be mistaken for agreement. A more uncomfortable point was also raised: the greatest threat to customary tenure sometimes lies within communities, where elite capture is enabled by proximity to schemes and power. Romanticising "the community" as a single, harmonious body is therefore unhelpful. Clans, landowners, women, youth and non-tourism households do not always want the same things, and women in particular are still confined to cooking, serving and performing while negotiations are conducted by men.

The proposal of a binding community veto over consequential decisions is bold and deserves debate. A credible veto encourages early negotiation and prevents surprises. But difficult questions arise. Where villages share water, trails or access, who counts as "affected" is far from settled. The rights of individual landowners, which were acknowledged, can collide with collective decisions. A veto exercised only by the loudest or best-connected voices would simply relocate the problem of capture. Safeguards such as published decisions, grievance channels and accountability of representatives are needed before such a power can be considered legitimate.

The state tourism department's presentation was, by contrast, largely descriptive. A familiar catalogue was provided: homestays, plastic-free zones, village tourism boards, training programmes and online registration. These are welcome, but no figures were offered on how much revenue actually reaches villages, how many boards function, or how visitor numbers are matched to water and waste capacity. The admission of persistent gaps, from poor roads and limited air connectivity to permit hurdles and untrained guides, was candid. Still, a policy that promises "high value, low impact" tourism cannot be judged until value and impact are measured and published.

The Hornbill Festival remains the elephant in the room. It is an established event with considerable institutional and commercial interest, and its effect on surrounding communities and resources has rarely been studied independently. The suggestion that the university take up a multi-disciplinary study is practical and should not be left to gather dust. A festival cannot be wished away, but it can be examined.

Caution against dependence on tourism is also well founded. The pandemic showed how quickly incomes vanish. Seasonality is built into the region, since visitors arrive in winter, when water is scarcest. Agriculture, crafts, forestry and local food systems should therefore remain the base, with tourism treated as a supplement. At the same time, the visible concretisation of villages, with gates and amenities replacing traditional houses, is more than an aesthetic complaint. It is a sign of how development is imagined. Still, aspirations for modern housing and better infrastructure are legitimate and should not be dismissed as lost authenticity. The challenge lies in finding designs that are both comfortable and rooted.

The way forward is not a choice between state and community. Authority must be located with the village, while capacity, transparency and funding are guaranteed by the state. Small pilots among a few villages, measurable benefits and honest evaluation should come before grand frameworks. Success is to be judged not by the number of arrivals, but by whether Naga communities remain the custodians of their land, water and institutions.



Support The Morung Express.
Your Contributions Matter
Click Here